( A ) X = 12, Y = 7 $\; \; \; \; $ True ribs are attached dorsally to vertebral column and ventrally to the sternum.
( B ) X = 24, Y = 7 $\; \; \; \; $ True ribs are dorsally attached to vertebral column but are free on ventral side.
( C ) X = 12, Y = 5 $\; \; \; \; $True ribs are attached dorsally to vertebral column and sternum on the two ends.
( D ) X = 24, Y = 12 $\; \; \; \; $ True ribs are dorsally attached to vertebral column but are free on ventral side.